The Former Judges Forum wants judges to check their own conduct, political meddling in appointments to stop, and everyone to sit down and talk about reform
Kathmandu, Nov 6. The alleged meeting between judges and a middleman has put the Supreme Court’s image under a cloud, and now the Former Judges Forum, Nepal has spoken up.
After media and social media reports about the conduct of some Supreme Court judges, the forum says it is stunned.
In a press release signed by chairperson Topbahadur Singh, the forum said it had taken note of the Supreme Court full court’s decision of Kartik 16 and the notice sent with it. The release does not name any judge or person.
The forum’s argument is simple. It describes itself as an organization that works for an independent, capable and accountable judiciary, one that people can trust. So when news came that Supreme Court judges had ignored judicial conduct, it hit hard.
It reminded readers what the code of conduct rests on: independence, impartiality, integrity, propriety, competence, equality and diligence. If judges do not stay alert themselves, it said, the code alone cannot protect the court’s dignity. The code was adopted precisely so that judges could show the public a record of honesty and clean conduct.
The forum also offered an easy test. Every judge must answer for their work and behavior. A judge should ask whether a sensible, reasonable observer would find their actions fitting for a Supreme Court judge. And to protect the court’s dignity, the forum believes judges should find a way out themselves.
But it points the other way too. The tendency to show the entire judiciary in a bad light, and to spread that image, because of one or a few judges should be stopped in time. On corruption and misconduct, though, it has no doubt: zero tolerance.
The forum traces the root of the problem to appointments. Making your own person chief justice or judge, against the spirit of the constitution, and then expecting favorable verdicts has pushed the courts to where they are, it says. Political parties and every other stakeholder should think about that.
It lists the symptoms. Seniority is skipped without stated reasons. Judges who lose faith in their own competence end up seeking political protection. Judicial leadership has not shown it can control and manage the court. And verdicts get read through a political lens instead of a legal one. Put together, the forum says, the judiciary looks like it is sinking a little more each day.
It raised one more concern. When evidence gathered from a person under investigation is made public in violation of legal procedure, the investigation and hearing can be damaged, so the responsible bodies should be careful.
So what now? Every allegation against a Supreme Court judge should be handled lawfully, with respect for judicial independence, and with expert advice if needed. The forum wants the constitutional process used to check whether the judges under suspicion broke the constitution or law, lacked competence, behaved badly or seriously breached the code, and whether real evidence exists.
Finally, it asked the responsible bodies to begin talks among all stakeholders on deep reform of the judiciary, including restructuring and the re-appointment of judges. It asked for talks to begin, not for re-appointment to happen straight away.
In effect, the forum has shifted the debate from one alleged meeting to how judges are appointed and how the court is built.



